Brief #6 - Why Do So Few Residents Return to Mixed-Income Developments? Insights into Resident Decision-Making

  • strict warning: Declaration of vsite::router() should be compatible with space_type::router($op, $object = NULL) in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 232.
  • strict warning: Non-static method vsite::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 228.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_og::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 204.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_type_purl::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/contrib/spaces/spaces_og/plugins/space_og.inc on line 185.
  • strict warning: Non-static method vsite::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 228.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_og::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 204.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_type_purl::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/contrib/spaces/spaces_og/plugins/space_og.inc on line 185.
  • strict warning: Non-static method vsite::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 228.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_og::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 204.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_type_purl::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/contrib/spaces/spaces_og/plugins/space_og.inc on line 185.
  • strict warning: Non-static method vsite::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 228.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_og::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 204.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_type_purl::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/contrib/spaces/spaces_og/plugins/space_og.inc on line 185.
  • strict warning: Non-static method flag_flag::factory_by_row() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/contrib/flag/flag.module on line 1424.
  • strict warning: Non-static method flag_flag::factory_by_row() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/contrib/flag/flag.module on line 1424.
  • strict warning: Non-static method flag_flag::factory_by_row() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/contrib/flag/flag.module on line 1424.
  • strict warning: Non-static method flag_flag::factory_by_row() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/contrib/flag/flag.module on line 1424.
  • strict warning: Non-static method flag_flag::factory_by_row() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/contrib/flag/flag.module on line 1424.
  • strict warning: Non-static method flag_flag::factory_by_row() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/contrib/flag/flag.module on line 1424.
  • strict warning: Non-static method flag_flag::factory_by_array() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/contrib/flag/flag.module on line 1506.
  • strict warning: Non-static method flag_flag::factory_by_array() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/contrib/flag/flag.module on line 1506.
  • strict warning: Non-static method flag_flag::factory_by_array() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/contrib/flag/flag.module on line 1506.
  • strict warning: Non-static method flag_flag::factory_by_array() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/contrib/flag/flag.module on line 1506.
  • strict warning: Non-static method flag_flag::factory_by_array() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/contrib/flag/flag.module on line 1506.
  • strict warning: Non-static method flag_flag::factory_by_array() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/contrib/flag/flag.module on line 1506.
  • strict warning: Non-static method vsite::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 228.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_og::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 204.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_type_purl::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/contrib/spaces/spaces_og/plugins/space_og.inc on line 185.
  • strict warning: Non-static method vsite::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 228.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_og::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 204.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_type_purl::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/contrib/spaces/spaces_og/plugins/space_og.inc on line 185.
  • strict warning: Non-static method vsite::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 228.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_og::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 204.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_type_purl::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/contrib/spaces/spaces_og/plugins/space_og.inc on line 185.
  • strict warning: Non-static method vsite::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 228.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_og::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 204.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_type_purl::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/contrib/spaces/spaces_og/plugins/space_og.inc on line 185.
  • strict warning: Non-static method vsite::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 228.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_og::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 204.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_type_purl::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/contrib/spaces/spaces_og/plugins/space_og.inc on line 185.
  • strict warning: Non-static method vsite::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 228.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_og::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 204.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_type_purl::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/contrib/spaces/spaces_og/plugins/space_og.inc on line 185.
  • strict warning: Non-static method vsite::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 228.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_og::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 204.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_type_purl::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/contrib/spaces/spaces_og/plugins/space_og.inc on line 185.
  • strict warning: Non-static method vsite::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 228.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_og::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 204.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_type_purl::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/contrib/spaces/spaces_og/plugins/space_og.inc on line 185.
  • strict warning: Non-static method vsite::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 228.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_og::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 204.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_type_purl::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/contrib/spaces/spaces_og/plugins/space_og.inc on line 185.
  • strict warning: Non-static method vsite::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 228.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_og::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 204.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_type_purl::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/contrib/spaces/spaces_og/plugins/space_og.inc on line 185.
  • strict warning: Non-static method vsite::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 228.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_og::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 204.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_type_purl::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/contrib/spaces/spaces_og/plugins/space_og.inc on line 185.
  • strict warning: Non-static method vsite::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 228.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_og::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 204.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_type_purl::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/contrib/spaces/spaces_og/plugins/space_og.inc on line 185.
  • strict warning: Non-static method vsite::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 228.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_og::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 204.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_type_purl::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/contrib/spaces/spaces_og/plugins/space_og.inc on line 185.
  • strict warning: Non-static method vsite::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 228.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_og::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 204.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_type_purl::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/contrib/spaces/spaces_og/plugins/space_og.inc on line 185.
  • strict warning: Non-static method vsite::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 228.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_og::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 204.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_type_purl::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/contrib/spaces/spaces_og/plugins/space_og.inc on line 185.
  • strict warning: Non-static method vsite::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 228.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_og::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 204.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_type_purl::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/contrib/spaces/spaces_og/plugins/space_og.inc on line 185.
  • strict warning: Non-static method vsite::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 228.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_og::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 204.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_type_purl::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/contrib/spaces/spaces_og/plugins/space_og.inc on line 185.
  • strict warning: Non-static method vsite::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 228.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_og::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 204.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_type_purl::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/contrib/spaces/spaces_og/plugins/space_og.inc on line 185.
  • strict warning: Non-static method vsite::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 228.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_og::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 204.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_type_purl::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/contrib/spaces/spaces_og/plugins/space_og.inc on line 185.
  • strict warning: Non-static method vsite::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 228.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_og::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 204.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_type_purl::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/contrib/spaces/spaces_og/plugins/space_og.inc on line 185.
  • strict warning: Non-static method vsite::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 228.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_og::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 204.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_type_purl::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/contrib/spaces/spaces_og/plugins/space_og.inc on line 185.
  • strict warning: Non-static method vsite::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 228.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_og::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 204.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_type_purl::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/contrib/spaces/spaces_og/plugins/space_og.inc on line 185.
  • strict warning: Non-static method vsite::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 228.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_og::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 204.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_type_purl::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/contrib/spaces/spaces_og/plugins/space_og.inc on line 185.
  • strict warning: Non-static method vsite::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 228.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_og::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/openscholar_vsite/vsite/plugins/vsite.inc on line 204.
  • strict warning: Non-static method space_type_purl::excluded_paths() should not be called statically in /web/archivessascholars/sites/all/modules/contrib/spaces/spaces_og/plugins/space_og.inc on line 185.

In the largest public housing reform effort in any city in the U.S., several high-rise public housing developments in Chicago have been demolished and are being replaced by mixed-income developments. Advocates for public housing residents have worked hard to negotiate a “right to return” to these new developments, which contain a mix of public housing replacement, affordable, and market-rate housing. Yet, as in other cities across the country, only a small percentage of residents, about 11 percent, have so far returned to the mixed-income developments. As a result, relatively few relocated public housing residents are directly benefiting from the major investment being made in mixed-income housing.

In this brief, we explore the factors that influenced relocated public housing residents’ decisions to return or not return to a mixed-income development. Through interviews with relocated public housing residents of three mixed-income developments in Chicago—Jazz on the Boulevard, Oakwood Shores, and Westhaven Park—as well as a group of residents who chose not to return, we find that the following issues significantly influenced resident decision-making:

  • Attachments to place and people
  • Time pressures and other constraints
  • Anticipated benefits from the mixed-income environment
  • Trade-offs and risks associated with moves to mixed-income developments

Read the brief here (PDF)

This brief is based on a longer paper, Mixed-Income Developments and Low Rates of Return: Insights from Relocated Public Housing Residents in Chicago (Joseph and Chaskin, 2012, Housing Policy Debate 22(3): 377-405).